One failed component does not mean a whole boiler needs replacing. Equally, a run of expensive faults may make further repair hard to justify. We recommend looking at evidence rather than a single rule about boiler age.
Reasons to consider repairing
A sound boiler with an identifiable, reasonably priced fault may have worthwhile life remaining. Parts availability and the general state of the appliance still need checking.
Reasons replacement may be more practical
Repeated failures, scarce components, poor overall condition or a system that cannot meet current demand can change the economics. If major modifications are needed anyway, compare the full cost of both options.
Questions to ask the engineer
What caused the fault? Are parts available? Is there another underlying issue? What is included and excluded from the repair price? A good diagnosis makes the decision clearer.
